This is part of my Sunday Sermons series, where I wrote rebuttals to the Baptist preacher’s sermons while I lived in Costa Rica.
(8/15 is Costa Rica’s Mother’s Day)
The scriptural passage today was from “Genesis” the first book of the Christian Old Testament, or a part of Jewish scripture, if you prefer.
Old man Abraham was entertaining three men, one of whom was God, the other two angels. God told Abraham that Abraham was going to have a son by his ninety-year old wife Sarah. They were childless but God particularly wanted Abraham to have a son so that a lineage could be started. Sarah overheard and laughed because she was so old to still be having “sexual pleasure,” which is a sweet way to look at procreation, and tells you right there that this is a Jewish story and not a Christian one. God later asked why she laughed. She was scared God would smite her, so she lied: she said she hadn’t laughed. God said, “No, but you did laugh.”
God asked Sarah why she laughed and Sarah lied out of fear. God was a smiter, so she was smart to try to avoid getting caught. But Sarah should have realized that she had the upper hand and didn’t need to lie. God had already said she would have the baby, so he couldn’t punish her by death on the spot, and if he waited until after the baby was born, the kid wouldn’t have the mother’s love necessary for starting a good lineage. He could decree that she would have a hard childbirth, but then, he already set that up in the first garden story. And what would Sarah say? “Hard childbirth? Well, duh!”
God had himself in a bit of a bind. Being God, he should have already known Sarah’s reasons for laughing. Maybe he was having a bit of an off day or, being male, maybe he just didn’t get female irony. Or, maybe he was paranoid about being laughed at. Whatever was going on, he forgot a basic rule of communication: Questions that begin with ‘why’ are rarely perceived as merely seeking information. Rather, they sound judgmental and laced with indirect criticism. You can’t really fault Sarah for getting a little nervous after a question like that. Talk about blaming the victim – God sounds just a wee bit defensive there.
Ok, so Sarah answered with a lie: “I didn’t laugh.” Now here’s where God could have taken back the upper hand simply by being consistent. “Sarah, why are you lying to me?” She still might have answered with a lie: “I’m not lying.” But she would know that the game was up. While the meaning of laughter might be ambiguous, everybody knows you’re not supposed to lie to God, so a why question at this point is simply setting the record straight. But, no, God lost the advantage by becoming argumentative: “I did not lie” – “yes you did” – did not, did – did not, did – there’s nowhere to go here, unless one of the two is brave enough to admit they need to start over. What are the odds that it’s going to be Sarah?
Well, we’ll never know, because the story veers into other territory at this point. When next we hear of Sarah, she is traveling with Abraham who has asked her “to do him a kindness” by telling people they meet that Abraham is her brother. Now, any modern married woman will start to get suspicious at this point. Sarah, on the other hand, probably figured that at 100, if Abraham can get a little action on the side, good for him. But, lo, at ninety, Sarah must have still been a looker, because one of the local kings decided to “take her.” It’s always been a king or nobleman’s right to sample the goods of his kingdom, especially on the “first night” of a marriage, which may be why we don’t have much royalty around anymore. But there aren’t many (any) stories of them testing the geriatric waters, which brings us to the question: How old was Sarah, really? Is the bible fudging just a bit?
Next we hear that God “did to Sarah as he promised,” which must mean he helped an egg slip down because we don’t hear about the other possibility until about 1300 pages later. So she had a son. Maybe Sarah was having a touch of post partum depression afterward, because now she was the touchy one about laughing. When her husband’s concubine laughed at such an old new mother, Sarah sent her and her son into the wilderness to die. Well, can you blame her?
Sarah continued on until 127 years old, the story goes, making her son 37 when she died. And for all her trouble, while her husband did mourn and weep for her, he found a burial place “out of his sight.”
The point of this story, as it was explained to me, was that nothing, even pregnancy, is impossible with God.
Here are some alternate sermon topics that might arise:
Elder sex
Beauty Is Only Skin Deep
Risks of late-life pregnancy
From Barren to Bearing
What Is Old?
Keeping A Sense of Humor
Lying to God
Changing The Rules
Second Chances
What Did Sarah Want?
8/16/2009